What Happens If an Excluded Driver Gets in an Accident?

Thursday, July 30, 2026

What Happens If an Excluded Driver Gets in an Accident?

Written by Malman Law, reviewed by Steve J. Malman.

An excluded driver is someone specifically removed from coverage under an insurance policy, and this status can create serious complications after a crash. This raises an important question: What happens if an excluded driver gets in an accident? The insurer typically denies the claim since that driver was never covered to begin with, leaving the vehicle owner responsible for all resulting damages out of pocket.

Legally, this exposure can lead to lawsuits and high costs for everyone involved, depending on the circumstances of the crash. A Chicago car accident lawyer at Malman Law can help by navigating the claims process, identifying other available sources of coverage, and working toward the best possible outcome for your case.

Looking For A Car Accident Lawyer Near You?

We’ll fight for the compensation you deserve.

Contact us now Call us now

Contact us now Call us now

What Is an Excluded Driver?

An excluded driver is someone who is not covered by a car insurance policy, even if they live in the same household as the car owner. This means if the excluded driver uses the car and gets into an accident, the insurance company won’t pay for any damage or injuries.

For example, let’s say your older brother has had many speeding tickets. Your parents might decide to exclude him from their car insurance policy to keep costs down. This means he’s not allowed to drive their car at all.

What Happens If an Excluded Driver Is Not at Fault?

Fault does not change how an insurance company treats the exclusion itself. Even when the excluded driver gets hurt or was not the cause of the crash, the insurer still denies any claim filed under a policy naming them as excluded.

So what happens if an excluded driver gets in an accident they did not cause? Recovery does not disappear entirely. If another driver caused the collision, the injured party, including an excluded driver acting as a victim, may still pursue a claim against the at-fault driver’s own liability insurance. The exclusion only blocks access to the policy the person was removed from. Other policies, including those held by the vehicle owner or a resident relative, may still respond and provide coverage when the primary policy will not. Clients often assume being blameless restores coverage under their own household policy, but it does not.

This scenario is why identifying every other available source of coverage becomes essential after a crash involving an excluded driver. Understanding why insurers draw this line in the first place helps explain how exclusions get put in place before an accident ever happens.

What Are the Reasons for Excluding Drivers?

Most people exclude drivers to save money on insurance premiums. Insurance companies charge higher premiums when risk factors, like accidents or traffic violations, are present.

For instance, if a driver is at fault for an accident in Illinois, they may end up paying up to 53% more on insurance rates. So, by excluding high-risk drivers from the policy, the overall risk decreases, and the policyholder is awarded a lower premium.

Also, excluding drivers helps prevent a policy from being canceled altogether, which is more likely in certain scenarios. In Illinois, policies can be canceled for various reasons, including a significant increase in risk. If a high-risk driver causes multiple accidents or receives numerous traffic violations, the insurer might decide to cancel the policy to mitigate their own financial risk. By excluding high-risk drivers, policyholders reduce the likelihood of such scenarios and maintain uninterrupted insurance coverage.

Additionally, some parents or guardians opt to exclude teen drivers. It is a way for them to deny teens driving privileges and avoid potential risks associated with inexperienced drivers.

Excluding vs. Removing Drivers From Car Insurance

Excluding a driver and removing a driver from car insurance sound similar, but they mean two different things. According to the Illinois Secretary of State, the distinction comes down to whether the person still lives in the household and whether the insurer still knows about them:

• Excluding a Driver: The person still lives in the household, but the insurer has agreed not to cover them if they drive the car
• Removing a Driver: The person no longer lives in the household and is taken off the policy entirely, so the insurer no longer considers them at all

A sister who moves out to attend college would likely be removed from the policy, since she no longer lives at home. A cousin with a poor driving record who moves in, on the other hand, might be excluded, since he still lives in the household but poses a risk the policyholder wants to avoid covering.

Consequences Of An Excluded Driver Accident

Excluded drivers sometimes get behind the wheel anyway, which raises a pressing question: What happens if an excluded driver gets in an accident? The results can lead to big problems:

• The insurance company will not pay for any damage to your car
• They will not pay for damage to other cars or property
• They will not pay for anyone’s medical bills
• The excluded driver might have to pay for everything out of their own pocket
• The car owner might get in trouble for letting an excluded driver use the car

These consequences often extend well beyond the initial accident, making it critical to understand all available recovery options before costs land squarely on the excluded driver or vehicle owner.

Insurance Coverage Options After an Excluded Driver Gets in an Accident

When an excluded driver gets into an accident, it can leave the car owner in a tough spot. One option to consider is uninsured motor vehicle coverage. This type of insurance helps cover costs if the accident involves a driver without insurance or is a hit-and-run. It can help pay for things like medical bills and car repairs.

According to the Illinois Department of Insurance, car owners are required to possess uninsured motorist coverage of at least $25,000 per person and $50,000 per accident. This means having uninsured motor vehicle coverage can give peace of mind, even after an accident involving an excluded driver. However, you will still need to have a legal advocate by your side, who can represent your rights properly and pursue compensation that reflects your losses.

Does Insurance Ever Cover an Excluded Driver?

When an excluded driver causes a crash in Illinois, the insurer generally denies the claim because the driver was specifically removed from the policy. This can leave the excluded driver, and in some cases the vehicle owner, personally responsible for medical bills, property damage, and other losses.

An excluded driver accident typically triggers one or more of the following outcomes:

• Denied Insurance Coverage: No payment for vehicle repairs, medical expenses, or liability claims tied to the crash, leaving those costs entirely on the driver’s shoulders.
• Personal Liability: Both the excluded driver and the vehicle owner can face legal claims from anyone injured or whose property was damaged in the collision.
• Legal Consequences for Uninsured Operation: Penalties under Illinois law, separate from any civil claim arising from the crash, may include fines or license suspension.
• Recovery Through Other Coverage: Injured parties may still pursue compensation through uninsured motorist benefits or a direct claim against the responsible parties.

Coverage almost never extends to the excluded driver directly, but injured parties are not left without options. Illinois requires insurers to offer uninsured motorist coverage under Illinois Insurance Code Section 143a, which can apply when the at-fault driver has no valid insurance of their own, a category often including excluded drivers. Reviewing every policy connected to the crash, not just the one naming the excluded driver, is often the only way to locate coverage willing to pay. Knowing this difference helps drivers understand what they could still owe even after coverage is denied.

Can an Excluded Driver affect the Overall Cost of my Insurance Premiums?

Excluding a driver typically lowers a premium, since the insurer no longer factors that person’s risk into the rate. The savings are not guaranteed, though. If a household owns only one car and excludes the only other licensed driver in the home, the insurer may view the arrangement as suspicious, since someone still needs to drive the vehicle day-to-day. That suspicion alone can push rates higher rather than lower.

Removing a driver from the policy entirely can produce the opposite effect from what most people expect. Fewer drivers on a policy sometimes raise the cost rather than lower it, since the same overall risk is spread across fewer people paying into it. A household that assumes cutting a driver always means cutting costs may find that the math works differently once the insurer recalculates the policy.

Anyone weighing whether to exclude or remove a driver should confirm the actual premium impact with the insurer directly, rather than assuming either option guarantees savings.

Do Excluded Drivers have any Recourse if They Believe They were Unfairly Excluded from a Policy?

If someone believes they were unfairly excluded from a car insurance policy, they do have some options:

• Talk to the policyholder and ask why the exclusion was made
• Ask the insurance company to explain the reason behind the exclusion
• Look for an individual insurance policy instead of relying on someone else’s
• Improve a driving record to demonstrate lower risk over time
• File a complaint with the state insurance department, in certain cases

For instance, someone who believes their parents excluded them by mistake could ask the parents to raise the issue with the insurance company. Someone with a clean driving record for several years could also ask to be added back onto the policy. When the exclusion involves a dispute over how or why it was applied, legal guidance can help clarify the person’s rights and the options available for challenging it.

Car Accident Lawyer Near Me

If you are looking for Car Accidents lawyers near your location, Malman Law is your best option. Located in Chicago, Illinois, our team is ready to help you recover the compensation you deserve.

Contact us now Call us now

Contact an Illinois Car Accident Attorney Today

Handling a car accident involving an excluded driver can be challenging, especially when the driver causes substantial property damage or severe bodily injuries. In these cases, the legal knowledge of a personal injury attorney makes a real difference in the outcome.

Knowing what happens if an excluded driver gets in an accident is only the first step. Malman Law has represented many clients through these situations and helped them pursue substantial settlements. Do not wait to take the first step toward securing your right to compensation. Contact us today at 1 888 625 6265 to schedule a free consultation with our experienced car accident lawyers.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can an excluded driver ever be covered?

In rare cases, yes. If the exclusion form was signed incorrectly, never properly delivered, or written in ambiguous language, an insurer may face a challenge over whether the exclusion was valid at the time of the crash. These situations are uncommon, and a policy that clearly and properly excludes a driver will hold up in most disputes.

Does every state allow excluded drivers?

No, not every state permits driver exclusions in the same way. Illinois allows insurers and policyholders to exclude a specific driver by written agreement, but the rules governing how that exclusion must be documented and disclosed vary from state to state. A driver moving between states should never assume an exclusion works identically everywhere.

Can I remove an excluded driver from my policy?

Yes, policyholders can generally request removal of an exclusion at any time. The process typically involves contacting the insurer, completing new paperwork, and accepting any resulting premium increase. Some insurers also require proof of an improved driving record before agreeing to add the person back onto the policy.

Will my insurance be canceled if an excluded driver causes an accident?

Not automatically. Because the excluded driver has no coverage under the policy, the insurer typically has no claim to pay and, therefore, no direct claims-based reason to cancel the policyholder’s coverage. The excluded driver, however, still faces personal exposure. Illinois Vehicle Code Section 3-707 makes operating a vehicle without valid insurance a criminal offense, carrying fines and license suspension separate from any civil claim arising from the crash.

Can I sue an excluded driver after an accident?

Yes, injured parties can file a lawsuit directly against an excluded driver. The exclusion only removes insurance coverage; it does not remove personal liability. The real challenge is often collection, since a judgment against an individual with no insurance and few assets can be difficult to satisfy. This is why a car accident lawyer will look beyond the driver, checking every other available policy for a source of recovery.